Secrets AI Alternatives: Match the App to Your Gripe

Secrets AI is a strong companion app. We rate it 9.9 out of 10, and the reasons are concrete: layered memory you can edit through Lorebooks, live voice calls, and adult video that actually renders. The people who cancel usually aren't disappointed in the product. They hit a wall — a $19.99 monthly bill, no app icon on their phone, or a group chat feature locked behind the $39.99 tier.

So this isn't a list of apps that beat Secrets outright. It's a list sorted by the reason you're leaving. Read your row, check the price, then decide. If your gripe isn't here, staying may be the smarter move.

Why people leave Secrets AI

Four complaints come up most often in user reports and forum threads.

• Price. Premium is $19.99 billed monthly. Annual drops it to $109.99, about $9.17/month, but that's a lump sum up front, and subscriptions are non-refundable except where the law requires otherwise. Crypto payments are never refunded.
• No mobile app. Secrets has no App Store or Google Play listing. It's a browser web app only. For some people that's fine; for others it means no companion in the pocket.
• The free tier is thin. Free users get 20 responses daily and no Moments at all — which means no images, no videos, no real voice calls. You can't judge the product's best parts without paying.
• Features behind Ultimate. Group chats of two or three companions, personas, proactive messages and personality editing all sit in the $39.99 tier.

There's also the Moments maths. An 8-second adult video costs 600 Moments. Premium's 8,000 monthly Moments don't roll over, so unused credit evaporates at the end of the billing cycle. If you mostly want pictures and clips, you're paying a premium subscription for a media budget that runs out.

One more thing worth flagging before you shop around: some roundups advertise a $13 annual Secrets plan. The official plan list has no such tier. Treat third-party pricing claims with suspicion, including the ones on this page — verify at checkout.

Pick by reason for leaving

Reason	Best pick	Why	Price from
$19.99/month steep for images	OurDream AI	Unlimited chat plus 1,000 dreamcoins, about 200 images	$9.99/month annual
Lowest annual price	Candy AI	Photorealistic images at $47.88/year	$3.99/month annual
No native app	Nomi, Kindroid	Native apps with long-term memory	$8.33/month Nomi annual
Group chat locked to Ultimate	CrushOn AI	Group chats on cheaper paid tiers	$5.99/month
Free tier: 20 messages, no images	Janitor AI, SpicyChat	Free roleplay with community character cards	Free
More appearance control	Nectar AI	Very detailed appearance and personality builder	$9.99/month
Gentler, less explicit	Replika	Emotional-support companion	$5.83/month annual

Alternatives at a glance

Platform	Best features	Free access	Native app
OurDream AI	Images and videos for less	1 dreamcoin per message, no images	No, web
Candy AI	Cheapest annual plan	5 chat messages total	No, web
Nomi	Memory and mobile companions	Limited messages	iOS and Android
Kindroid	Voice and video calls	50-message preview	iOS and Android
CrushOn AI	Cheap roleplay tiers, group chat	100 message credits monthly	Not verified
Nectar AI	Character creation and roleplay	15 messages + 10 generations daily	Not verified
Janitor AI	Free story roleplay	Yes	No
SpicyChat	Free character library	Yes, with queue	Android
Replika	Emotional support	Friend mode	iOS and Android
HeraHaven	Simple girlfriend roleplay	Limited	Not listed

The cheaper media route: OurDream AI

If your objection is the bill, OurDream AI is the closest like-for-like swap. It's $19.99 monthly or $9.99/month billed $119.88 yearly, and the yearly plan bundles unlimited chat with 1,000 dreamcoins a month — roughly 200 images or ten short videos.

The currency maths is where it wins against Moments. Video runs 100 dreamcoins per five seconds, up to 60 seconds, so a full minute costs 1,200 coins. Voice calls cost 50 coins per minute. Compare that to Secrets' 600 Moments for 8 seconds of adult video and you can see why heavy image users migrate.

The catches are real, though. The free tier charges 1 dreamcoin per message and gives no images at all — some guides claim 50 messages and 5 images daily, which isn't what the pricing page says. Memory leans on recent messages rather than a long arc, so it's weaker than Secrets on recall. And media gets blurred if your subscription lapses.

The privacy picture needs care too. The homepage claims end-to-end encryption; the privacy policy describes server-side encryption and permits training on user data. Those statements don't match. Our OurDream AI review digs into the gap, and the OurDream AI vs Secrets AI comparison lines the two up side by side.

The cheapest annual plan: Candy AI

Candy.ai undercuts almost everyone on annual pricing: $3.99/month, or $47.88 for the year. Monthly is $13.99, quarterly works out at $8.99/month. A few roundups quote $4 to $6/month; the current advertised rate is $3.99, so check before you commit.

What you get for that is the best character creator in this group. Ethnicity, age, body, hair, personality, voice and hobbies are all adjustable, and faces stay consistent across hundreds of generations. Voice notes, beta voice calls and image-to-video are in the product. Some roundups claim 120-second clips — that's unconfirmed.

What you don't get is memory. Testers report conversations resetting after two or three days. If you left Secrets because you wanted a companion who remembers your job, your ex, your dog, Candy will frustrate you. The token model is another trap: Premium includes 100 tokens monthly, an image costs about 4, so that's 25 images. Heavy users report $25 to $80/month in top-ups. The free plan is five messages total, and refunds only apply within 24 hours on card payments with 20 tokens or fewer used. Our Candy.ai review has the full breakdown, and Secrets AI vs Candy AI covers the memory trade directly.

If you need a real app: Nomi and Kindroid

No browser bookmark replaces a home-screen icon. Two options have genuine iOS and Android apps with long-term memory.

Nomi is $15.99 monthly or $99.99 yearly, about $8.33/month. One subscription covers up to ten companions, and group chats are included. One review reports 40 shared images daily. Explicit text is allowed; nude images are not. Credits sell from $4.99 for 40.

Kindroid is $15.99/month through the app stores, $13.99 on the website as reported. It's the most feature-dense on voice: voice cloning, real-time voice, live video calls, and texting over iMessage or Android RCS. The costs stack. Voice packs run 500,000 credits for $14.99, and Live Avatar video is about 2,500 credits per minute on top of the call charge. Ultra and MAX add-ons are extra. The free option is a one-time 50-message preview, then read-only; the 3-day trial requires a payment method.

Neither has Secrets' editable Lorebooks. If you were using those to correct what your companion believes about you, you'll miss them.

Cheap group chat: CrushOn AI

Group chat on Secrets means $39.99 Ultimate. CrushOn AI puts group chat on paid plans starting at $5.99/month for Standard, $14.99 for Premium, with tiers up to $199.99/month. Free users get 100 message credits monthly plus unlimited access to free models, and context runs 8K free, up to 24K on paid tiers.

It's text-first. Images and video are weak, so don't switch here expecting the visual side of Secrets to follow you. Free history is deleted after seven days of inactivity.

More control over appearance: Nectar AI

Nectar AI runs $9.99, $19.99 or $34.99 monthly, with about 50% off annual. The free tier gives 15 messages and 10 generations daily. Reviewers count 300+ options in the builder; some roundups say over 350. Voice pricing is unconfirmed.

Watch the top-ups. Reviewers report $60 to $75/month at moderate usage, and encryption and data retention are unclear. If customization is the whole reason you're switching, Nectar delivers it. If you want predictable bills, it doesn't.

Free text roleplay: Janitor AI and SpicyChat

Janitor AI is free, including its own model, and supports bringing your own API key. Janitor+ launched in June 2026 at $12.99/month, adding about five times the context and priority messages. There are no images, video, voice or calls — it's a writing tool with characters.

SpicyChat has a free tier with no hard daily cap but a queue. Paid tiers are $5.95, $19.95 and $29.95 after a September 2026 price rise. The complaint that shows up most is reply quality: free and $5.95 replies are capped at 180 tokens, which produces short or repetitive messages. It has an Android app.

Neither free option has images, adult videos and voice calls. If that's what you used Secrets for, free apps are a downgrade, not a substitute.

Gentler tone: Replika

Replika runs about $5.83/month annually and is built for emotional support rather than explicit chat. No explicit content, and romantic modes need a paid plan. Replika 2.0 adds voice conversations and real-time video calls per its own site. Italy's regulator fined the operator €5 million in 2025 — worth knowing if you care about how these companies behave under scrutiny.

Other names you'll see

HeraHaven is $19.95 monthly or $6.65/month annually, with 500 Luna tokens monthly covering chat and images. Users report quality degrading after a few hundred messages, and refund terms are unverified.

Kalon AI claims real-time voice without extra currency, image generation without a separate media currency, and cross-session relationship history. Plans are unverified. Xotic AI roundups claim trait-based building and 4K clips up to 15 seconds — also unverified. Cherrypop.ai's blog says users can shape appearance and behavior; that's a vendor claim, not a review.

Treat all of these as leads to check, not recommendations.

Pricing comparison

Platform	Monthly plan	Best per-month price	Media currency
Secrets AI Premium	$19.99	$9.17 annual	8,000 Moments
Secrets AI Ultimate	$39.99	$26.67 annual	15,000 Moments
OurDream AI	$19.99	$9.99 annual	1,000 dreamcoins
Candy AI	$13.99	$3.99 annual	100 tokens
Nomi	$15.99	$8.33 annual	Credits
Kindroid	$15.99 app	$13.33 annual	Selfie and voice credits
CrushOn AI	$5.99 to $199.99	Varies	Tier credits
Nectar AI	$9.99 to $34.99	About 50% off annually	Credits

Sticker price is only half the story. Candy's $3.99 annual still leaves you buying tokens for images. Kindroid's annual looks reasonable until you add voice packs and Live Avatar minutes. OurDream is generous on chat but charges per message on free accounts. Budget by real usage, not by the headline number.

Memory and conversation quality

This is where Secrets earns its score. Companions remember prior conversations and calls, and paid tiers widen recall. Lorebooks let you edit what a character knows — a feature nobody else in this list matches.

Nomi and Kindroid are the closest on long-term memory and were built for it. OurDream leans on recent messages. Candy resets after two or three days per testers. CrushOn's context stretches from 8K to 24K depending on tier, which helps within a session more than across months.

If memory is why you stayed with Secrets this long, switching to Candy or OurDream will feel like a downgrade. Switch to Nomi or Kindroid instead, and accept the trade.

Images, video and voice

Secrets charges 50 Moments per image, 600 per adult video, and 50 per minute of voice call. Premium's 8,000 Moments buy 160 images or about 13 videos. Ultimate's 15,000 stretch further.

OurDream is cheaper per unit: 100 dreamcoins per five seconds of video, 50 per minute of voice. Candy produces the most consistent faces but charges 4 tokens per image on a 100-token monthly allowance. Kindroid has the deepest voice stack — cloning, real-time, video calls — at add-on prices. Nectar's media costs are unclear, and Janitor has none.

Character builders and roleplay

Candy's builder is the most granular on appearance. Nectar's is close on options but less proven. Secrets offers personality editing and personas, but only on Ultimate. CrushOn is the cheapest place to run group roleplay. Janitor and SpicyChat lean on community character cards rather than deep builders of your own.

Privacy and safety

None of these platforms offers true end-to-end encryption for conversations. Some marketing pages imply otherwise; read the privacy policy, not the homepage.

Secrets encrypts data at rest with AES-256, deletes history immediately on account deletion, and doesn't store voice audio — but its data may be used to train models. OurDream claims end-to-end encryption on the homepage while its policy describes server-side encryption and permits training. Nectar's encryption and retention are unclear. Candy's refund window is 24 hours.

There's history here too. A 2024 breach at Muah.ai exposed about 1.9 million email addresses plus users' prompts. Assume anything you type could surface. Keep real names, workplaces and photos of real people out of chats, and delete the account — not just the app — when you leave.

How to choose

1. Name your gripe in one sentence. Price, app, free tier, group chat, visuals, memory.
2. Find the row in the first table that matches. That's your shortlist.
3. Check the media currency, not just the subscription. Multiply by your real usage.
4. Read the refund policy before paying. Most are strict; crypto is almost never refunded.
5. Check the privacy policy for training and retention language.

Should you just stay with Secrets AI?

If your complaint is vague — the app feels expensive, the interface is fine but not exciting — staying is reasonable. Secrets remains one of the strongest companions available, and the annual Premium plan at $109.99 cuts the monthly cost to about $9.17. Ultimate's annual rate is $26.67/month if you need group chat and proactive messages.

Switch when the gripe is specific and the alternative fixes it. OurDream for cheaper media. Candy for the lowest annual price. Nomi or Kindroid for a native app. CrushOn for affordable group chat. Nectar for customization. Janitor or SpicyChat for free text roleplay. Replika if you want something gentler.

Every switch trades something away. Pick the limits you can live with, not the feature list that looks longest.