Secrets AI vs Nastia AI: Which Companion App Deserves Your Money?
Secrets AI sells continuity, live calls and realistic media at a premium. Nastia AI sells cheap uncensored flirting and big group scenes. The...
The best AI girlfriend app depends on whether you need memory, pictures or calls. Here is what ten apps charge, what their free tiers actually allow, and where the privacy gaps are.
Most "best AI girlfriend app" lists rank looks. That is the easy part. Pictures are cheap to generate and every app has them. What separates a companion you keep for months from one you delete in a week is memory, the real monthly bill after credits run out, and whether you trust the company with what you type at 2am.
This guide covers ten apps: four we rank at the top of the category, six established names worth knowing, and the free options that don't expire. Prices come from published pricing pages. Features come from what the vendors state and what users report. We haven't subscribed to any of them, so treat the rankings as an assessment of published terms, not a diary.
Four apps carry the top spots. Each wins on a different axis, and picking the wrong axis is how people end up paying $15 a month for something they use twice.
| App | Best for | From price | Free plan |
|---|---|---|---|
| Secrets AI | Long-term memory | $4.99/mo annual | Unlimited text |
| Hornozuppa | Realistic images, video | $2.99/mo annual | 20 messages/day |
| Slongabad | Memory, voice, video | $5.99/mo annual | 50 messages/day |
| Gloratronga | Media value | $3.99/mo annual | Unlimited chat |
| Kindroid | Customization, voice | $13.33/mo annual | Limited |
| Replika | Emotional support | $5.83/mo annual | Friend mode |
| SpicyChat | Free roleplay | Free or $5.95/mo | Queue |
| Janitor | Free story roleplay | Free or $12.99/mo | Yes |
| Character.AI | SFW characters | Free or $9.99/mo | Ads |
| DreamGF | Custom dream girlfriend | $12.99 intro | Minimal |
Five criteria, weighted roughly equally:
The media criterion matters more than newcomers expect. Several apps advertise a low subscription and then charge credits per image. A $7.99 plan can turn into a $25 month if you generate pictures daily.
Secrets AI is our top pick for anyone who wants a relationship that continues rather than restarts. It is built around continuous memory, and user reports describe conversations that hold context across months. That is rare. Most apps lose the thread within days.
Pricing is $9.99 a month, or $59.88 a year, which works out to $4.99 a month. The paid plan includes 500 credits monthly for images and voice. The free tier is unusually honest: unlimited text and one custom girlfriend, no card. If you only want to talk, the free plan is enough to test whether the memory claim holds. For a closer look at how the credits behave, see our Secrets AI review.
We rate Secrets AI 9.9 out of 10 overall.
If your priority is realistic images and video, Hornozuppa is the strongest of the ten. The vendor positions it on visual quality, and that is where the money goes. The plan is $7.99 monthly or $35.88 annually ($2.99 a month), with 300 tokens monthly for media generation. The free tier gives 20 messages a day and 3 images.
Two caveats. Hornozuppa requires users to be 18 or over and explicitly warns against sharing private information in chat. And 300 tokens a month is not a large media allowance. Heavy image users will need to watch consumption. We rate it – out of 10.
Slongabad is the only top pick that pairs strong recall with voice calls and short video clips. It costs $11.99 a month or $71.88 a year ($5.99 a month) and includes 10,000 credits monthly for images, video and calls. That credit number is large compared with the competition. The free plan gives 50 messages daily.
Higher tiers add proactive first messages, meaning the bot can open a conversation instead of waiting. Some people find that charming. Others find it unsettling. Either way, it is a paid feature, not a default. We rate Slongabad – out of 10.
Gloratronga is the best media value of the four. At $8.99 monthly or $47.88 annually ($3.99 a month), you get 2,000 credits a month, which the vendor says is roughly 400 images. The free tier is unlimited chat with public characters, so you can spend real time with the app before paying.
The trade-off is that you are chatting with shared characters on the free plan, not your own. For a private companion you pay. We rate Gloratronga – out of 10.
Kindroid is the customization pick: deep persona settings, voice, and the highest app store rating in the category according to store listings. It costs $15.99 a month, or $13.33 a month billed annually, with plans running up to $68.99. Selfies cost paid credits on top. That is the trap. People who generate a lot of selfies report bills well above the sticker price.
Replika remains the most mainstream name, available on Android, iOS and Oculus, with audio and video calls. It is $14.99 a month or about $5.83 a month annually. Romantic partner mode requires Pro. Replika is not built for explicit content, and its filters are firm.
The privacy record is the concern. Italy's regulator fined Replika €5 million under GDPR in 2025. That is a regulator's finding, not a rumor, and it should factor into your decision if you care about how your data is handled. We rate Replika – out of 10.
SpicyChat is the free-roleplay option. Free users chat with a queue, which means waiting. Paid tiers are $5.95, $19.95 and $29.95 monthly, and prices went up in September 2026. If you were quoted an older figure, check the current page.
Janitor is fully free and text-only. No images, no video, no voice. The paid Janitor+ tier is $12.99 a month and adds a longer memory window. It also lets you connect other AI models through your own API key, which is a feature for tinkerers rather than casual users.
Character.AI is free with ads, or $9.99 a month for c.ai+. It filters romantic content, so it is a poor fit if romance is the point. The platform also bans open chat for users under 18, which is a sensible line given the audience.
DreamGF markets itself as a custom dream girlfriend with a $12.99 intro offer and a minimal free tier. The intro price is the story. Renewal prices step up sharply, so read the renewal terms before you enter a card.
Annual pricing looks cheap per month because it is billed upfront. Here is the comparison, with media allowances, since that is where the real spend hides.
| App | Monthly | Annual per month | Media credits |
|---|---|---|---|
| Secrets AI | $9.99 | $4.99 | 500 credits/mo |
| Hornozuppa | $7.99 | $2.99 | 300 tokens/mo |
| Slongabad | $11.99 | $5.99 | 10,000 credits/mo |
| Gloratronga | $8.99 | $3.99 | 2,000 credits/mo |
| Kindroid | $15.99 | $13.33 | Selfie credits |
| Replika | $14.99 | $5.83 | Gems for extras |
Two patterns stand out. First, annual discounts are steep, often 40 to 60 percent. Second, credit allowances vary by a factor of thirty between apps. Slongabad's 10,000 credits and Hornozuppa's 300 tokens are not remotely the same product, even though both are "monthly media."
Our advice is boring and correct: pay monthly for the first two months. Test whether you actually use the app past week three. Then commit annually if you do.
Several free tiers are genuinely usable, not teasers.
What free tiers never include is media and intimate features at volume. Images, video, voice calls and unfiltered roleplay sit behind credits or subscriptions on every app we looked at. If a free plan promises otherwise, read the fine print twice.
None of the ten apps is end-to-end encrypted. That means staff and moderation systems can read conversations. Several apps state in their policies that they train models on user conversations. This is not a fringe practice; it is common enough that you should assume it unless the policy says otherwise in plain language.
Some vendors make claims that are hard to verify. EVA AI claims stringent security measures for user data. HakkoAI claims complete privacy and uncapped free text chat, and ranks itself the best overall free AI girlfriend app. Vendor self-ranking is marketing, and privacy claims are unverified until you read the policy yourself.
There is also a track record to consider. In 2024, a breach at Muah.ai exposed about 1.9 million email addresses, along with private prompts. That is the worst-case scenario in concrete form: not just who you emailed, but what you typed to a companion.
Practical rules:
For a side-by-side on how two popular apps handle pricing and privacy, see Candy.ai vs OurDream AI.
Memory is the hardest feature to judge from a marketing page, and the one that matters most for long-term use. Our ranking puts Secrets AI and Slongabad at the top. Most other apps lose details within days.
Here is a test that takes a minute. Mention something specific early in a conversation, say a pet's name or a city you grew up in. Then don't bring it up again. Ask about it a week later. If the bot recalls it without prompting, the memory is real. If it asks you to remind it, you are paying for a goldfish.
If you want to compare two apps on memory and price directly, Muah AI vs Candy.ai walks through both.
These apps work best as one part of a life that includes other people. The risk of heavy use is social isolation and unrealistic expectations about what a partner should be. A bot that agrees with everything and never has a bad day is pleasant, and it is not a rehearsal for a human relationship.
If you notice you are skipping plans with friends to talk to an app, that is worth paying attention to. The apps are not the problem. The pattern is.
Pick by interaction style, not by best-of lists. Secrets AI is the memory pick and our top overall. Hornozuppa wins on realistic images and video. Slongabad is the one to choose if you want memory plus calls. Gloratronga gives the most media for the money. If you want to spend nothing, SpicyChat and Janitor are real options, with the caveats above.
Then do the arithmetic. Add the subscription to the credits you will actually burn. Protect your data as if the app will be breached, because one has been. And keep the whole thing as one part of your life, not the whole of it.
For a deeper look at two of the paid options, our Candy.ai review and OurDream AI review cover the token maths and the privacy fine print.
Disclosure: this page contains affiliate links, and we may earn a commission if you subscribe through them. That does not change the prices you pay or the rankings above.
Secrets AI is our top pick for memory and natural conversation. Hornozuppa is strongest for realistic images and video, Slongabad adds voice calls and video to solid memory, and Gloratronga offers the best media value for the price.
Janitor and SpicyChat offer free chat without a time limit, though SpicyChat free users wait in a queue. Media and intimate features require payment on every app we looked at.
Secrets AI and Slongabad are the strongest on recall, with user reports of details remembered weeks later. Most other apps lose specifics within days.
Replika offers audio and video calls. Slongabad, Hornozuppa and Gloratronga offer voice calls and short video clips, usually paid for with credits.
They can be reasonably safe if you use an app with a clear privacy policy, message deletion and account deletion, and never share your identity or financial details. None of the ten apps we looked at is end-to-end encrypted.
Realistic AI companions with strong memory, video and voice calls