Secrets AI vs Nastia AI: Which Companion App Deserves Your Money?
Secrets AI sells continuity, live calls and realistic media at a premium. Nastia AI sells cheap uncensored flirting and big group scenes. The...
Most people don't leave OurDream AI because it's bad. They leave because of one specific thing — memory, credits, privacy or platform. Here's how to match a replacement to the reason.
OurDream AI is not a bad deal on paper. $19.99 a month, or $9.99 a month if you pay yearly ($119.88), and 1,000 dreamcoins a month lands in your account. That's roughly 200 images. Videos run up to 60 seconds. The homepage claims over 11 million characters.
So why do people go looking for something else? Usually one specific thing. A model that forgets the plot. A media bill that outruns the subscription. A privacy policy that says something different from the marketing page. Or the simple fact that there's no app — everything lives in a browser tab.
This is a matching guide, not a takedown. For the full breakdown of what OurDream costs and where the fine print bites, read our OurDream AI review. If you've already decided to move, start with the reason you're moving.
| Leaving because | Best pick | Price from | Free tier |
|---|---|---|---|
| Memory fades | Secrets AI | $9.17/month annual | 20 messages a day |
| Cheaper polished images | Candy AI | $3.99/month annual | 5 messages total |
| Slow-burn relationship | Kupid AI | $13.99/month | Limited |
| Native phone app | Nomi | $15.99/month | Limited messages |
| No per-message pay | SpicyChat | Free ($5.95/month paid) | Yes, with queue |
| Story-first roleplay | Janitor AI | Free ($12.99/month Janitor+) | Yes |
| Unfiltered on budget | CrushOn AI | $5.99/month | 100 credits a month |
| Huge character choice | GirlfriendGPT | $15/month reported | Yes, limited |
| Game-like dating | DreamGF | $25.99/month | Minimal |
| Warm affectionate chat | Nectar AI | $9.99/month | 15 messages a day |
Four complaints come up again and again, and they're worth naming before you shop.
In-chat images cost 5 dreamcoins. Video costs 100 coins per 5 seconds. At 1,000 coins a month, that's 200 images — or ten 5-second clips and nothing else. Some guides describe OurDream as unlimited; unlimited messaging is Premium-only, and media is metered on every plan.
OurDream does not publish a context window. In practice, users report threads that drift once a conversation gets long. If you're running a slow story with one character, that hurts more than any pricing change.
The OurDream homepage promises end-to-end encryption. The privacy policy describes server-side encryption only — at rest and in transit. The policy also permits using your data to train AI models. No platform in this roundup has verified end-to-end encryption, but the mismatch between the two pages is the thing to know about.
OurDream is browser-only. No native app. No PayPal. English-only. Account deletion takes 24 to 48 hours per policy. And if your plan lapses, your generated media stays blurred until you resubscribe — it isn't deleted, but it isn't yours to view either.
If your complaint is forgetting, Secrets AI is the most direct replacement. Premium is $19.99 a month or $109.99 a year — about $9.17 a month — with 8,000 Moments. Ultimate is $39.99 and adds group chats with two or three companions.
Media pricing: images 50 Moments, adult videos 600, voice calls 50 per minute. The free tier gives 20 messages a day with no media generation. Moments don't roll over, and purchases are largely non-refundable. On privacy, Secrets uses AES-256 encryption at rest, deletes chat history when you delete your account, and doesn't store voice audio — but it may train on chats. We rate Secrets AI 9.9 out of 10. For the deeper comparison, see OurDream AI vs Secrets AI and our Secrets AI review.
Candy.ai is the pick if images are the point and you want to pay less for them. $13.99 monthly, $8.99 a month quarterly, or $3.99 a month on the annual plan ($47.88) with 100 tokens. Images cost about 4 tokens each — roughly 25 images a month on the base allowance. The free tier is 5 messages total, which is a demo, not a trial. Refunds must be requested within a day and are capped at 20 tokens spent.
Candy offers 13 interface languages and takes cards, Apple Pay, Google Pay and crypto. The trade-off is memory: testers report story threads that can reset within days. We rate Candy.ai 9.8 out of 10. Our Candy.ai review and Candy.ai vs OurDream AI go deeper.
Kupid AI Premium is listed at $13.99 a month or $84 a year, with an Ultimate tier at $49 a month and a lifetime plan at $777. Those figures come from third-party reviews, not Kupid's own pricing page — treat them as reported, not confirmed. Kupid's appeal is pacing: relationships that build over time rather than instantly. Media pricing isn't published.
Nomi costs $15.99 a month or $99.99 a year and ships native iOS and Android apps. If you're leaving OurDream because you're tired of a browser tab, that alone may settle it. Nomi's help wiki states it does not send nude photos, so it's a poor fit if explicit images are the reason you subscribed in the first place. We rate Nomi – out of 10.
SpicyChat claims 100 million registered users and runs its own SpicyXL model. Paid tiers are $5.95, $19.95 and $29.95 a month after a September 2026 price increase, with yearly billing about 17% off. Free users face a queue. There's no video and no iOS app, though there is an Android download. We rate SpicyChat – out of 10.
Janitor AI is fully free including JanitorLLM, with a bring-your-own-API-key option. Janitor+ launched in June 2026 at $12.99 a month or $8.25 a month yearly, adding five times the context and priority responses. There's no image, video or voice generation at any tier, and the Discord community is close to 400,000 people. We rate Janitor AI – out of 10.
CrushOn AI Standard is $5.99 a month, with a price ladder that climbs to $199.99 a month. The free tier gives 100 message credits monthly, and free chat history is deleted after 7 days of inactivity. Top tiers carry memory up to 24K, and there are 20+ models with an Unfiltered filter option. Yearly billing works out to about $4.90 a month. Its Trustpilot rating was 1.8 from 22 reviews as of October 10, 2026 — small sample, but not encouraging. We rate CrushOn AI 8.8 out of 10.
GirlfriendGPT plans are reported at $15, $35 and $50 a month with 400, 1,200 and 2,000 coins, and around 20 coins per video. Those prices are not confirmed on an official page. Yearly is reported at $12 a month. There's no native mobile app. We rate GirlfriendGPT 8.9 out of 10.
DreamGF is $25.99 a month with 100 tokens; an image costs 10 tokens and a voice call 7 per minute. The annual offer is $69.99 for the first year, then renews at $311.88 — read that line twice. It offers discreet billing, voice messages and calls. We rate DreamGF 9.1 out of 10.
Nectar AI tiers are $9.99, $19.99 and $34.99 a month, with a free tier of 15 messages and 10 generations daily. It charges credits per message, and one reviewer estimated $60–$75 a month in extra credits on top of the subscription. Yearly is reported at 50% off. We rate Nectar AI 9.6 out of 10.
Nastia's Unlimited plan is $15.99 for unlimited messages, 4K selfies and 1080p video, with group chats up to 10 characters; the free version is uncensored per Nastia. Replika focuses on emotional support, has native apps and voice calls, and isn't built for NSFW media. Character AI blocks NSFW outright. LusyChat's claims are unverified by independent data, and Yume AI was left out for lack of verified data.
| Platform | Monthly | Best long-term | Media payment |
|---|---|---|---|
| OurDream AI | $19.99 | $9.99/month ($119.88/year) | 1,000 dreamcoins monthly |
| Secrets AI | $19.99 | $9.17/month ($109.99/year) | 8,000 Moments monthly |
| Candy AI | $13.99 | $3.99/month ($47.88/year) | 100 tokens monthly |
| Kupid AI | $13.99 | $84/year reported | Not published |
| Nomi | $15.99 | $99.99/year | Credits |
| SpicyChat | $5.95 | About 17% off yearly | Tier unlocks |
| Janitor AI | Free / $12.99 | $8.25/month yearly | No media |
| CrushOn AI | $5.99 | $4.90/month yearly | Message credits |
| GirlfriendGPT | $15 reported | $12/month yearly reported | Coins |
| DreamGF | $25.99 | $69.99 first year, then $311.88 | 100 tokens monthly |
| Nectar AI | $9.99 | 50% off yearly reported | Credits |
One pattern holds across the table: no platform here offers unlimited images. Every app meters media through coins, tokens or credits. Any ad promising unlimited image generation deserves suspicion.
OurDream's 1,000 monthly dreamcoins buy about 200 images at 5 coins each, or video at 100 coins per 5 seconds — 60-second clips are possible but expensive. Secrets AI charges 50 Moments per image and 600 for adult video, so its 8,000 monthly allowance covers 160 images or 13 videos. Candy's tokens are the cheapest per image at roughly 4 tokens each, but 100 tokens a month is a small bucket.
For video specifically, Secrets and OurDream both offer it; SpicyChat and Janitor AI do not. Voice calls exist on Secrets, Candy (beta), OurDream, Nomi and DreamGF. If you're switching mainly for media, compare the per-image cost, not the headline subscription price.
This is where most switches are won or lost. Secrets AI markets memory as its main feature and charges for it accordingly. CrushOn AI publishes memory up to 24K on its top tiers. Candy's story threads can reset within days according to testers. Nomi is built around a consistent companion persona. OurDream doesn't publish a context figure at all.
If you're running long-form roleplay, pay for memory. If you're generating images with light chat around them, don't.
Only Janitor AI is genuinely usable free long-term, and it has no media. Everything else is a trial.
No app on this list has verified end-to-end encryption, OurDream included. OurDream's homepage says end-to-end; its privacy policy describes server-side encryption and permits training on user data. Secrets uses AES-256 at rest, deletes chat history on account deletion and doesn't store voice audio — but may train on chats. Crypto payments are final at both OurDream and Secrets. Candy's refund window is one day. OurDream's refund terms contradict each other between the guarantee page and the help center.
If a privacy claim appears on the marketing page but not in the policy, believe the policy.
OurDream AI is still strong value for media volume at $9.99 a month yearly. Switch only for a clear reason. If memory is the problem, go to Secrets AI. If you want cheaper annual images, Candy.ai. If you want an app on your phone, Nomi. If you want free roleplay, SpicyChat or Janitor AI. If you want budget unfiltered chat, CrushOn AI.
And before you cancel: OurDream media goes blurred after your plan lapses until you resubscribe. Purchased coins stay, but free features don't. Decide what you're giving up before you click.
Secrets AI is the closest like-for-like swap if memory is your main complaint, and it keeps images, video and voice calls. Candy.ai is the better pick if polished images at a lower annual price matter more than continuity.
Janitor AI is fully free for text, including JanitorLLM, and SpicyChat is free with a queue. Neither matches OurDream's image and video generation, so free means giving up media.
OurDream, Candy.ai and Secrets AI are web apps you add to your home screen. Nomi and Replika have native iOS and Android apps, and SpicyChat offers an Android download but no iOS app.
SpicyChat runs its in-house SpicyXL model, Secrets offers several models, and Janitor AI lets you bring your own API key. Most platforms here don't disclose which models they use.
They aren't deleted, but they stay blurred until you resubscribe. Purchased coins remain, though free features don't.
No. The homepage claims it, but the privacy policy describes encryption at rest and in transit only. The policy also permits using data to train models, and moderation filters sit in the path.
Realistic AI companions with strong memory, video and voice calls